Ask an expert


Kaza&^}

Hi I am trying to decide on which would be better a 2010/11 Wing road or the 2006/7 Caldina. I can spend up to 10,000. The majority of Wingroads I have seen are 2005/6 and 2007 models and I know about their cvt problems. The Caldina's are really popular and for a 2007 model the price is the same as for the Wingroad Im wondering why this is and is the Caldina a better car. Also do you think a 2010 model WIngroad that is quite a bit over 100,000 km would be better if I know its history has been immaculate rather than less km and not knowing? I need something with space for caring art work about and long trips hence the Wingroad seems good. Any advice would be really appreciated, thank you.

Anon

Hi there,
My choice would be the Caldina, due to larger engine and more reliable transmission type.
The CVT on the nissan may be better by 2010 but there is a possibility it is the old type still.
Comes down to personal preference really.
Knowing the vehicle history is a positive, and would give you a piece of mind when buying.